Dec 6, 2008

Columnists - Khushwant Singh

I was reading Paul Johnson’s Intellectuals for the second time. It’s a highly readable series of essays on the role of intellectuals in Europe and the United States. The writings of some of them like Karl Marx, Friedrich Nietzche, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Leo Tolstoy, Jean-Paul Sartre and Bertrand Russell had a profound and lasting effect on generations of Europeans and Americans. India also produced intellects like Rammohun Roy, Sri Aurobindo and M.N. Roy. It has also some highly educated and perceptive thinkers today. But their impact on Indian society has been, and is, marginal. Why ?

I can assign two reasons for the failure of our intellectuals to change society. One is that all of them wrote in English that barely 10 per cent of educated Indians can read and comprehend. The masses never get to know about them. The second, and the more important factor in isolating intellectuals was, and is, the fact that the vast majority of our countrymen look up to their gurus or godmen for guidance because they speak their language.

It is oral and not written communication. Gurus have massive following but their learning is limited to churning out accepted religious concepts unaffected by occidental learning. Most of their pravachans (lectures) are accompanied by hymn singing and at times dancing in ecstasy. Their congregations return to their homes contented and at peace with themselves because they do not have to wrestle with new ideas. That is why caste distinctions persist, foeticide is widely practised and we continue to breed at a suicidal rate. Our gurus never deal with such social problems.

I am not sure if my reading of the ineffectiveness of Indian intellectuals in changing social attitudes is correct. I hope to have readers’ reactions.

11 comments:

Dr.V.N.Sharma said...

Dear Sardar Ji,
I read your Column in the Hindustan Times of today where you have referred to your second reading of Paul Johnson's book Intellectuals.
I found all your observations as correct with regard to the marginal influences of Indian Intellectuals.

However, I would like you to add one more weakness of the Indian Intellectuals and gurus. They all believed in leaving their knowledge in whatever field of specialisation or achievement they had only to one of their children or one of their disciples. They never gave it to the people at large. There are examples galore of this variety of Indian Intellectuals. Today West has gone up because they develop knowledge and share with any body and everybody of course for a fee which is called patent fee but the people get the benefits. Indian intellectuals fail to do that even today.

Buy penis enlargement pills said...

Thanks a lot for sharing, i am hoping I will start reading some of his essays very soon.

VigRX effective penis enlargement supplement said...

They never gave it to the people at large. There are examples galore of this variety of Indian Intellectuals.

African Mango weight loss supplement said...

It was worthy. I really got pleasure reading it. I am astonished to see your effort.

HghEnergizer anti aging treatment review said...

Our countrymen look up to their gurus or godmen for guidance because they speak their language.

Natural penis augmentation pills said...

India also produced intellects like Rammohun Roy, Sri Aurobindo and M.N. Roy.

Natural no side-effects phentermine said...

There are several different techniques out there you can use for male enhancement.

African Mango weight loss supplement said...

Paul Johnson is awesome writer .

Top Rated Vacuum Cleaners said...

I knew some things before i read you article, but now i can trully say that im an expert and want to thank you from my heart!

Fitoderm effective acne removal product said...

The reason of becoming a failure is really logical.Thanks for sharing it.

Top models clothing 2012 said...

A friend of mine told me about your blog and after reading this article i must go to him and personally thank for sharing your blog with me.